News

The halted egg price dispute in South Korea: From mistrust to cooperation

Clash between the government and the Egg Layer Association over causes of soaring egg prices.

The halted egg price dispute in South Korea: From mistrust to cooperation

The South Korean government canceled the corporate establishment license of the Korea Egg Layer Association, a producers’ group, and imposed a multi-hundred-million-won penalty, citing allegations that it fueled egg price hikes through collusion. However, the courts have repeatedly put a halt to these actions.

Previously, as reported by the Asia Business Daily, when the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs revoked the association’s corporate establishment license on July 29, the association filed for an injunction to suspend the execution of the order.

The Seoul Administrative Court accepted this request on August 31, and on September 18, the Seoul High Court also granted an injunction requested by the association that challenged the legitimacy of a USD 438,000 penalty imposed by the Fair Trade Commission, finding the sanction unjust.

The courts cited as grounds for their decisions the recognition of an urgent need to prevent irreparable harm to the association, and judged there to be insufficient evidence that suspending these administrative actions would have a significant adverse impact on the public interest.

Separate from its injunctions, the association has also filed lawsuits arguing that the Ministry’s and the Fair Trade Commission’s measures themselves are unlawful.

As a result of these injunctions being granted, the effectiveness of each of these measures will be suspended until 30 days after the rulings in the main cases are delivered.

Of note is the conditional provision attached by the courts. In its ruling, the Seoul High Court stipulated that the association must provide regional supply and price trend information—that it has been collecting and sharing—to stakeholders, but only after prior consultation with the Fair Trade Commission.

The focus was placed on requiring the association to communicate with the government instead of unilaterally announcing its own reference price for eggs, which forms the basis for distribution and consumer prices.

Looking back

Looking back, the conflict between the government and the association, which escalated to a legal battle, stemmed from mutual distrust of each other’s roles.

With consumer prices for 30 eggs having surpassed USD 7.38 this year, the government pointed to alleged collusion by a particular producers’ association (the Korea Egg Layer Association) as the cause. It argued that the association’s actions in setting and announcing producer prices restricted fair competition within the market.

The association, on the other hand, argued that the government was shifting the blame onto producers’ groups because measures such as the large-scale distribution of imported eggs failed to lower prices as much as hoped.

There is also a view that the government penalized the association because it raised on-the-ground concerns and suggestions regarding major policies, such as expanding per-bird cage space to improve laying hen welfare, thereby being seen as an obstacle.

Egg consumption is rising

Amid this fierce conflict between the two sides, egg consumption, a kitchen staple, has been rising. According to Dabom, the livestock distribution information system of the Livestock Products Quality Evaluation Institute, from January through August this year, a total of 354.73 million packs (each pack containing 30 XL eggs) were sold at nationwide hypermarkets, chain stores, and cooperative markets—a 38.5% surge compared to 256.17 million packs during the same period last year.

Since eggs are a fundamental source of protein for ordinary households, infrastructure and policies must be enhanced to reduce the price burden and provide a stable supply.

Before engaging in finger-pointing, the government and the association should reflect on the meaning of the court’s rulings, which urged both parties to cooperate to some extent.

Related to Trends

MAGAZINE AVINEWS INTERNATIONAL

Subscribe now to the poultry technical magazine

DISCOVER
agriNews Play - Los podcast del sector ganadero en español
agriCalendar - The events calendar of the agricultural worldagriCalendar
agrinewsCampus - Training courses for the livestock sector